Catholic Education and Artificial Intelligence


                Long story short; last June, just a few months after I started writing this blog, I was asked to apply for a PhD program in theology, specifically to research and write about an anthropological and dialogical perspective on Catholic pedagogy. I call it a “Theology of Catholic Pedagogical Theory”. I was quickly accepted to the program, but the timing and the funding wasn’t right, so that is on the backburner right now. In the meantime, I am continuing to write this blog (and three others). My Hope is to use this blog as a sort of sounding board or test-kitchen for ideas that, if I do go back to school, I can properly research and fashion into legitimate theology and/or pedagogy. We’ll see. But I am glad I am writing this; just this last weekend I was having dinner with my wife and her parents, and the conversation turned to Artificial Intelligence. My mother-in-law was talking about how within the foreseeable future, medicine will likely go entirely to Artificial Intelligence. I thought about education. What effect will AI have on education?
Veronica offers to wipe the face of Jesus in the Stations of the Cross in the Cathedral of Our Lady Assumed into Heaven and St. Nicholas in Galway, Co. Galway, Ireland. As teachers and as human beings, nothing will ever replace the efficacy of human touch and human interaction. We are made for such things. (photo P. Smith)

                Undoubtedly, Artificial Intelligence will, one day instruct students better than any human teacher could. I am careful to use the word “instruct”. The science of education really can be boiled down to ones and zeroes. Know the student and know the subject; identify how the student will best learn and retain given information; repeat, recycle. I am concerned. Certainly AI could be more efficient with instruction and grading. Maybe even helping students to identify their weaknesses and strengths in the classroom. That is what AI does. There is no way getting around that. So what can we do? What does this mean for Catholic education, in particular?
                I was already talking with my PhD promoter about possible thesis topics before potential funding ran out, and, well, without getting too much into the details, I came to the conclusion that I wanted to write about topics related to Catholic pedagogy being fundamentally different from most contemporary educational paradigms. That is, as I have written before, the fundamental purpose of Catholic education (or any education, I argue) is relationship with God for the purpose of the student knowing that she or he is Beloved. Education cannot be limited to simply getting into college or getting a job or even becoming a “well-rounded person”. Education is drawing forth from within the Truth that we are made to be in relationship with others…we are made to Love and to be Loved. Education is about relationship. It is not just about facts and figures and terms and ideas in the classroom, but also with the people in our lives. Catholic education should echo the image and likeness of the Trinity. Instruction, which I admit will almost assuredly be dominated by Artificial Intelligence in the near future, is merely a praxis within which one can contemplate human purpose and the Authentic Self. The deeper magic of education is not in the grades students earn; the magic of education is in the Truth of the human person… Truth that the human person is made to Love and to be Loved. It is not a matter of either/or in the case of human versus machine; I will gladly let a machine write lesson plans for me a grade! It is a matter of dialogue between human and machine, remembering that what my students will always desire most (because it is in their ontology) is an authentically Loving relationship with a human being who freely chooses to Love them. Maybe we need to express this clearly in our Catholic Pedagogy.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Reflective Teaching

Image
                My professional goal this year is to be more reflective. Reflective teaching, as most educators know, is really just the practice of taking a few moments at the end of the day to produce some sort of artifact demonstrating that you have thought about your lessons that day. Many teachers naturally think about what they have taught. For me, that is usually in the car on the way home while I metaphorically kick myself for not having the best comeback to a snarky comment I got from that one student. It isn’t a productive kind of reflection; you might just categorize it as a sort of “decompression” or “venting” exercise. But this year I have made a promise to myself that I would be more productive in my reflection. The result of my goal-setting, as it turns out, has become another tool for my students.                 At the...
Read more

Cristo Rey Atlanta Jesuit High School

Image
"Thanks for your response. It sounds like you have been reading a lot of Aquinas, in addition to your reference from Augustine! Indeed, human intellect can discern creation and free will to be gifts from God. By creating us and by giving us Free Will, God invites us into a relationship with Him. We must be given Faith in order for us to be able to freely respond to that invitation. If we accept that invitation we do it by our own Free Will...if we accept that we are Loved by God, it is an act of Faith. If we extend that invitation to Love and to be Loved, it is an act of Faith that we choose to make. As a teacher, I pay attention, especially, to those students who do not know they have been invited into a relationship with God...they do not know they are Loved. My primary goal is to extend that invitation to them. Regardless of what you teach or what your job is at a Catholic school (or any school, really) is to make sure our students know they are Loved. What a great mission we...
Read more

Our Students are More than Just their Grades

Image
“Thanks for your response. I like the points you make about some elements of Faith being given and some elements being chosen. Indeed, most theologians point to St. John when the make the claim that we are Loved first by God, regardless of anything we choose or desire. The quote I use with my students is "we are Loved into existence", simply because God is Love. In this way, we are created with a disposition to Faith as Faith is an invitation into a relationship with God. It is our response to the Faith God gives us that is Faith in action. It is my favorite concept to teach my students, and it is the blessing of any Catholic school teacher to help their students know they are called to be Loved and to Love.”             We are created with a disposition to Faith and a disposition toward the mystery of the transcendent. So why do we, as teachers, try to simplify Faith, religion, or theology as just a subject? Why would we limit ...
Read more