Humble Dialogue


                “It is not my job to make my students hate Henry James the way I hate Henry James.” Dr. Coia, one of my education professors, gave me this advice. I refuse to use my classroom to promote political or personal ideology. I had a student come to me after school, nearly in tears. As she tells the story, she had come from a class where the teacher consistently seemed to vilify students who disagreed with said teacher’s beliefs. If the purpose of Catholic Education is to help students encounter God and to know their Authentic Self, then I cannot think of a more counter-productive way to do this than to denigrate or cut down our students. Instead of beginning with the presupposition that either one or the other of us present in the classroom is right or wrong, why are we not simply teaching our students to be in dialogue with each other? In this particular case, it was a matter of the teacher having to be right all the time, and if the students didn’t agree, then it was the students’ who were unwilling to learn. If we are made in the image and likeness of the Trinity, and if that Trinity is in perfect relationship with itself, then it makes no sense to focus on who is right or wrong. The Father does not dominate the Son and the Holy Spirit! Maybe we can learn from the Trinity here. Maybe we can humble ourselves like the persons of the Trinity humble themselves. Maybe we can seek dialogical relationship with our students rather than dictatorial monologue.
The Knock Basilica in Knock, Co. May, Ireland. The apparition at Knock was particularly interesting, Mary said nothing. She stood silently, adoring the Lamb. The Word of God, humble Himself, spoke for us all. Perhaps as teachers we should look to our students as Mary looked to her Son and let them speak. 

                There is much more I can say about this; I want to be careful with how I word this, but I will stop here. Let me end this short blog with a simple statement: the goal of education is to teach students that they are Loved and that they can Love; this can really only be done by developing a culture of humble dialogue in the classroom.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Reflective Teaching

Image
                My professional goal this year is to be more reflective. Reflective teaching, as most educators know, is really just the practice of taking a few moments at the end of the day to produce some sort of artifact demonstrating that you have thought about your lessons that day. Many teachers naturally think about what they have taught. For me, that is usually in the car on the way home while I metaphorically kick myself for not having the best comeback to a snarky comment I got from that one student. It isn’t a productive kind of reflection; you might just categorize it as a sort of “decompression” or “venting” exercise. But this year I have made a promise to myself that I would be more productive in my reflection. The result of my goal-setting, as it turns out, has become another tool for my students.                 At the end of the day, I take about five minutes to review and reflect on the lessons I taught. I already write too much, so I thought I would just do a bi
Read more

I Wish I Knew What Catholic School Identity Was

Image
                What is Catholic School Identity? What does it mean when a school puts that little word “Catholic” on their sign or in their mission statement? I have been working on this question for some time now, and, to be honest, I want to keep researching. I want to really dive into the depths of what it means when we say that our schools are Catholic. St. Pius X Catholic High School in Atlanta, Georgia. My alma mater, St. Pius definitely deepened my understanding of Catholicism on an academic level, but I am sure that my relationships with teachers, students, and priests at St. Pius, at least, equally gave me an encounter with Jesus Christ which really sparked my Faith now. But are Catholic schools even more than this? (photo P. Smith)                 I have asked colleagues and contacts around the world what they think and the answers vary. I do not want to exhaust the space on this blog (I rarely want my blogs to be longer than just a few paragraphs), but suffice it
Read more

Our Students are More than Just their Grades

Image
“Thanks for your response. I like the points you make about some elements of Faith being given and some elements being chosen. Indeed, most theologians point to St. John when the make the claim that we are Loved first by God, regardless of anything we choose or desire. The quote I use with my students is "we are Loved into existence", simply because God is Love. In this way, we are created with a disposition to Faith as Faith is an invitation into a relationship with God. It is our response to the Faith God gives us that is Faith in action. It is my favorite concept to teach my students, and it is the blessing of any Catholic school teacher to help their students know they are called to be Loved and to Love.”             We are created with a disposition to Faith and a disposition toward the mystery of the transcendent. So why do we, as teachers, try to simplify Faith, religion, or theology as just a subject? Why would we limit in our classrooms (regardless of discipline)
Read more